Sunnis & Shias: Arab Nationalism Is The Answer - Instablogs
Sunnis & Shias: Arab Nationalism Is The Answer
Marco Villa , Connecticut: Feb 27 2009
Made Popular Feb 27 2009

Sunnis & Shias: Arab Nationalism Is The Answer

A while back I reported on riots in the Bahrain capital of Manama by the islands Shias against the Sunni ruling elite. The island is two-thirds Shias, but the Sunnis emir denies the Shias many of the privileges that the minority Sunnis receive. Although the island is very wealthy, many Shias live in slums while hardly any Sunnis do due simply to state discriminatory policies. That is not all though. The Shias also face unfounded accusations of disloyalty to the state in favor of nearby Shia Iran.

Bahrain was the only nation that saw such Shia protests against a Sunni government. In Saudi Arabia - where Shias account for 10% of the population - riots also broke when a member of the Saudi infamous religious police recorded Shia women attended pilgrimage. The husbands’ of the women complained about the invasion of privacy and instead of criticizing one of their own, the religious police instead arrested some of the protesting men. Riots then broke among the nation’s Shias. The riots have since subsided.

The Shias are an oppressed minority in the Gulf. They are denied the equal rights and in an fundamentalist Saudi Arabia are often vilified as heretics. During the Saudi riots, Sunni extremists - mostly Saudi - took to Arab news sites to vilify Shias. Calling them “rejectionists” in Islam and calling for a Saudi “iron fist” to be used against them. One vile commentator even calling for driving the Shias into the Persian sea.

I confronted one Sunni extremists on IB who left dismissive comments on my story calling for supporting the Shias in Bahrain. These people are fundamentalists whose racism for Shias is not shared by most Arabs.

The answer to dealing with conflicts between Shia masses and the Sunni political establishment is simply and obvious: get rid of Sunni-exclusive privileges and embrace Arab nationalism.

Shia Arabs are proud Arabs just like most Arabs. The Arab spirit: language, history, food, culture, music, the experience is a strong force that pulls in all in the region [with the exception of those Lebanese Christians who follow the fascist philosophy of the Phalange party]. When Iran recently stated that Bahrain is an old Iranian island and implicitly implied that it should be again, the same Shias oppressed by the Bahrainian government strongly rebuffed Iran and stated their proud Arab identity. Their response caused Iran to apologize to Bahrain. Shias also “[joined]a chorus of Arab protest that led some commentators to remark pointedly that several Iranian provinces happen to house large Arab and Sunni populations.”

As The Economist [cited above] further notes: “Considering local, regional and international variables, a clash between the Saudi regime and its Shia citizens is a matter of time, reads an ominous analysis on a popular Saudi website.”

Shias have every right to riot in Saudi Arabia until they earn their proper rights. All Arabs nations - and this applies to just the Gulf countries and Lebanon - need to put aside such lines of division and embrace the all-inclusive Arab identity. Only this will starve off any conflicts between Sunnis and Shias.

Arab nationalism is still the identity that stirrers Arabs into unity: the unites Arabs behind Palestine and made them cry out for Iraq. Arab nationalism is the answer for Arabs.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Almaha
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Arab nationalism is just an aspect of pre-Islamic ignorance. As a Muslim , there is no unity to me except on Islam.
Being Arab to me means nothing .My identity is Islam.And Approving of Arab nationalism would mean I do not care about non-arab Muslims.
As for saying shia are oppressed in the gulf, I lived in the east of Saudi Arabia where the majority of shia live. We got along so well and we never had any problems. I did not see the oppression you are talking about. And what are these rights that shia don’t have in Saudi Arabia you are talking about?
Shia in the gulf support Iran by the way, so saying the answer is Arab nationalism is something you should rethink.
1 Stars
Marco Villa benaliwatch.blogspot..
Connecticut, United States
It is people like you whom are the problem Almaha. First of all, Arab nationalism does not mean we don’t care about Muslims elsewhere, but what Arab nationalism is about is that in our own countries, region we should never let any religious difference be paramount over the ideal of Arab brotherhood. And the Shias don’t support Iran, that is nothing more than a lie. The Shias do not look to Iran for guidance and resent Iranian effort to speak on behalf of Shia Arabs. I wrote in the post, when Iran claimed Bahrain as an island it was the Shias who quickly rebuffed Iran and proudly stated their Arab identity. And what do you mean by ”support Iran”? Do you mean that they support Iran’s effort to get a nuclear weapons? Because I got news for you: most Sunni Arabs do as well. In fact, it is only the disgust ing Saudi royal family that is opposed to Iran because it does want Iran to challenge Saudi hegemony in the Gulf. And the Shias are oppressed, especially in Saudi Arabia where the religious establishment of Salafi zealots routinely call them heretics. Many Shias have been killed in Saudi Arabia simply for calling for equal rights. If things continue as they do, it will be only a matter of time until the Shias really revolt against the House of Saud. I will not rethink Arab nationalism, my Arab identity - unlike you - means the world to me. I am a Muslim too [Sunni] and there is no conflict between Muslim unity [Umma] and Arab nationalism. I hope that living in Saudi Arabia did instill in you the perverse Wahhabi ideology that is anti-Shia. If you truly want everyone to get ”along so well” then you should embrace Arab unity which is Arab nationalism. Unfortunately, you Gulf Arabs are lacking in Arab nationalism. Gulf Arabs are focused to much on the na rrow state that supports them through welfare. Ironic. The region from which the Arabs spread is today the region that guards the Arab nation less than others. The Gulf is humiliating under the thumb of the U.S. army. Remove the yoke of imperialism and raise your head up high again.
1 Stars
Steven Gary
melbourne, Australia
Hi Marco dont fall for Osamas claptrap about trying to unify the muslim arab to a return of the glory days of early Islam, when unity brought strength and conquest.

Theres too many conflicts of national interests to sacrifice for unity within the region.

And how can you be certain that if Iran got nukes they wouldnt start to oppress the Sunni countries and start to throw its weight around, after it gained diplomatic immunity from the imperialists via its nukes?

Maybe the individual countries trust each other less than the (so called) imperalists because they might have a worse situation then when the (imperialists) had an influence.

Like when the Ottoman empire took over or something and instead of acting in unity, one strong one dominates conquers and takes over the rest.

What would be your opinion if this scenario occurred do you mind or is it still better than situatin now?

I agree that the best thing about unity would be a decline in the Sunni Shiah violence against each other. I like if the more fundamental people could be more tolerant of some variant of beliefs.
1 Stars
Marco Villa benaliwatch.blogspot..
Connecticut, United States
Arab nationalism has nothing to do with Ussama Bin Ladin. It existed before that terrorist was born. He has nothing to do with it. You obviously don’t know what Arab nationalim entails. As for Iran, of course it will use its status to push weight around. But I don’t see that being harmful
1 Stars
Almaha
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
so you deleted my comment?lol
Of course you did:)
What happened to freedom of opinion:P
1 Stars
Marco Villa benaliwatch.blogspot..
Connecticut, United States
I have no idea what you’re taking about. I did not delete your comment. I don’t have the ability to do so. I don’t know who did?
Add your Comment