Neomi Klein: Never Again to Anyone - Instablogs
Neomi Klein: Never Again to Anyone
Marco Villa , Connecticut: Jun 28 2009
Made Popular Jun 29 2009
Palestine :

Neomi Klein: Never Again to AnyoneAs a sincere classical liberal, I am not the biggest fan of what Neomi Klein has to say. But on Palestine, her and I are soul mates.

Klein wrote a piece in The Nation magazine this past January finally coming out in support of a boycott of Israel. Klein made a good point. We should boycott Israeli institutions, but not the entire Israeli people some of whom are good individuals whom we need on our side to bring about an end to the occupation:

For eight years, my books have been published in Israel by a commercial house called Babel. But when I published The Shock Doctrine, I wanted to respect the boycott. On the advice of BDS activists, I contacted a small publisher called Andalus. Andalus is an activist press, deeply involved in the anti-occupation movement and the only Israeli publisher devoted exclusively to translating Arabic writing into Hebrew. We drafted a contract that guarantees that all proceeds go to Andalus’s work, and none to me. In other words, I am boycotting the Israeli economy but not Israelis.

Now Klein has visited occupied Palestine. Where she added,

“It’s a boycott of Israeli institutions, it’s a boycott of the Israeli economy,” the Canadian writer told journalists as she joined a weekly demonstration against Israel’s controversial separation wall.

“Boycott is a tactic ...we’re trying to create a dynamic which was the dynamic that ultimately ended apartheid in South Africa,”

“It’s an extraordinarily important part of Israel’s identity to be able to have the illusion of Western normalcy,” the Canadian writer and activist said.

“When that is threatened, when the rock concerts don’t come, when the symphonies don’t come, when a film you really want to see doesn’t play at the Jerusalem film festival... then it starts to threaten the very idea of what the Israeli state is.”

Klein also stated that Israel is practicing “apartheid, this is absolutely a system of segregation.”

But of all her words, she was none more eloquent than in talking about the Jewish tradition she was raised in:

“There is a debate among Jews. I used to say the Jewish community then I got excommunicated. There is a debate among Jews–I’m a Jew by the way” that boils down to: “Never again to everyone, or never again to us?... [Some Jews] even think we get one Get away with genocide free card... There is another strain in the Jewish tradition that says, ‘Never again to anyone.’”

If only more Jews would adopt that principle.

[To listen to her speech click here.]

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
Never Again to Anyone!
2 Stars
Michael Davison
Raanana, Israel
Naomi Klein: “I am boycotting the Israeli economy but not Israelis.”

This has got to be one of the most idiotic statements I’ve read in a long time. Any country’s citizens eat or starve, live or die with their country’s economy. For anyone to say that “I’m boycotting the economy but not the people” is a blatant self-deception. With this statement, Ms. Klein has reduced herself in my eyes to the worst kind of liar—a person who can lie to themselves. Anyone else who can believe the statement is also either a fool or a self-deceiver.

I agree with her on the principle of “Never again for anyone”—but she seems to be blind to some real facts on the ground and just as gullible as the dullest knife in the drawer when it comes to buzzwords and slogans.

Where is her concern for Rwanda, Darfur, Zimabwe and a dozen other points around this tortured globe where real massacres and real genocides are taking place, while she concentrates on a manufactured and false claim of genocide?

Where is her recognition of the declared Hamas objective of Israel’s destruction?

Where is her recognition of the massacres committed by Palestinians against Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank?

Another of her blatant lies is: “I used to say the Jewish community then I got excommunicated.”

Even I, as a secular Jew, know that Judaism has no concept of excommunication and that the closest thing to it is only practiced in the most ultra-Orthodox communities—and even there, only very rarely and for very specific reasons—it’s similar to the “shunning” of the Amish, and is called “cherem”, which, oddly enough, means boycott. I wonder if she isn’t simply practicing some kind of twisted “counter-boycott” for her own personal reasons.
Add your Comment