Louis Brandeis And the American Left - Instablogs
Louis Brandeis And the American Left
Marco Villa , Connecticut: Sep 25 2009
Made Popular Sep 25 2009
United States :

The late Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis is one of the most beloved of lawyers among American liberals. Brandeis was one of the socialists members of the court in history, a support of nearly every imaginable government control on the economy. “I am rapidly becoming a Socialist,” he once declared.
Louis Brandeis And the American Left
Besides Marxism, Brandies had another love: Zionism. Brandeis never lived to see the birth of modern Israel, but he worked ceaselessly to rally American Jewish in support of the Zionist movement (Brandeis was never a practicing Jew). Brandies’ support for Zionism was during a time when most American Jews were either indifferent or opposed. Most American Jews were anti-Zionist in the early years. America was their “Promised Land,” and many Jews feared that the establishment of a Jewish state would raise questions of dual loyalty. It was only the horrific nature of the Holocaust that galvanized American Jews in support of a Jewish state.

But Brandies was an only convert, and while Brandies preached enlightenment values of equal rights and human rights as an American lawyer like a many Zionists he did not apply those values when it came to the Holy Land.

Brandies was not only a Zionist, but one whom was entirely racist and indifferent to the Arabs in Palestine. For Brandies, the Zionist cause was one where the rights of Arabs in the Holy Land simply did not matter.

“As against the Bedouins, our [Zionists] pioneers are in a position not unlike the American settlers against the Indians,” he once wrote.

What is Brandeis saying here? Brandeis knows what happened to the Indians at the hands of American settlers: White Europeans settlers massacred millions of Indians, pushed them off their land, humiliated then and endlessly subjugated them. Brandeis is not shocking by such matters, simply because he followed a philosophy of believing that their are superior people - Westerns - and that they have ever right to conquer and enslave the savage inferiors - Everyone Else.

Brandies argues precisely that for Palestinians: that Jewish “pioneers” so treat Palestinians akin to the way Indians were treated by European “pioneers.” And both people have their myths: the latter “Manifest Destiny” while Israeli have “a land without a people for a people without a land” and “made the desert bloom.”

Brandies was an ardent Zionist, and his racism and contempt for the right of Arabs is the core of Zionist ideology. And Brandies was a man of the Left and still beloved by liberals, and in that he illustrates the manner in which American liberals still approach the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: one of romanticize of Israeli crimes and dehumanization and shunning of Palestinians.

Never a more vapid people.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Elizabeth
Washington, United States
I find myself wondering why Reform, Conservative and Reconstructionist synagogues continue to wrap every event in the Israeli flag when (since the Israeli Rabbinate is staunchly Orthodox and the Israeli government is totally controlled by Orthodox interests) Israel does not even acknowledge us as Jews (if we or our mothers converted under non-Orthodox auspices) and depending on our ethnicity, we may not even be allowed to make Aliyah. Believe me, that can be a heartbreaking realization. I think there is way too much conflation between Judaism and Zionism.
1 Stars
Sean
Los Angeles, United States
There is misogyny is Israel, like in every other country in the world. There is racism in Israel, like in every country in the world. There are a lot of wrong things with Israel, and with this world. Israelis are just humans....
1 Stars
Sami
Burlington, United States
To different people, Israel means different things, but I believe that we should support it's existance, especially as an option for those who are not as lucky to live in a country where Jews are as well assimilated as in America.
1 Stars
Jamie
Vancouver, Canada
I still believe that amongst the majority of minority groups, Jews are in generally more acceptable of differences between members of our religion and other ethnic/religious groups. That is not just some mantra I like to repeat to myself, but something I have experienced first hand living in Brazil, Belgium and the United States.
1 Stars
Marco Villa benaliwatch.blogspot..
Connecticut, United States
Certainly that does not apply to Zionist Jews whom harbor deep hate for Arabs and Israelis do not even treat Arab citizens with respect let alone those Palestinians in the occupied territories.
1 Stars
Michael Davison
Raanana, Israel
Mr. Villa loves to make generalizations demonizing anything he sees as “Zionist”.

MV: “Certainly that does not apply to Zionist Jews whom harbor deep hate for Arabs and Israelis do not even treat Arab citizens with respect let alone those Palestinians in the occupied territories.”

This statement is made from thousands of miles away, without ever having been in Israel or the Palestinian territories, without ever having made his own observations or reached his own conclusions. Hatred based on second- or third-hand evidence seems to be the hallmark of Mr. Villa.

I will not deny that there are Israelis who deeply hate Arabs—just as there are Arabs who deeply hate Israelis, but I wouldn’t generalize either case to include ALL Israelis or ALL Arabs as haters.

Respect, Mr. Villa, is something that has to be earned, not something given freely or blindly without being worthy of respect. Can you name any Arab deeds towards Jews in recent history that can make Arabs worthy of being respected by Israelis?
1 Stars
Marco Villa benaliwatch.blogspot..
Connecticut, United States
Respect from Israelis? Do you thing we Arabs give a shit about what Israeli thing of us let alone if they respect us? NO, we don’t care to enter into any relationship with Israelis. We don’t care if Israeli love us or hate us. That in the end will not matter. We don’t care to live alongside Israelis. And it is not us whom need to ask for Israelis to like us, but the other way around. It is Israelis whose long-term existence is conditional on Arab acceptance. It is Israelis whom need to worry about what their neighbors think. But, for the record, any gesture from Israelis will be properly rebuffed. History is a long affair, and while Israel is powerful today, Rome once stood powerful too (not to compare that colonial-state to the great empire in anything but terms of military might in one’s domain)

And you typically behave as if the Israeli Jews are the innocent ones here. Once again positioning the nation that has committed one massacre after another and continues to occupy millions of people as the morally superior, righteous one instead of a criminal terrorist state as it is. As if it is their goodwill that needs to be earned by Arabs. As if they are the aggrieved party. Only Zionists like you believe that.

The historical record is clear: it was European Zionists whom struck the first blow. It was they whom started a cycle of violence between Arabs and Jews when they committed ethnic cleansing and massacres of Palestinians in 1948, and razed their villages afterward. And stole their land. It was they whom demonized the Arabs when the Arabs had allowed Jews to prosper in ways that was forbidden in the West and the Arabs never committed the pogroms and Holocaust, and then spread myths about themselves being ”the Chosen People” with the ”Promised Land” and making ”the desert bloom.” It is they, Israeli Jews, whom disrespect.

The question needing to be asked is: What have Israeli Jews (and all Zionist Jews) done to earn the respect and acceptance of Arabs?

P.S. If your response is going to be another one of your typical, boring and infamous 11-page essays then do not bother since I do not waste time reading such posts.
1 Stars
Michael Davison
Raanana, Israel
MV: “We don’t care to live alongside Israelis.”

Finally, a bit of truth, after all the lies.

MV: “The historical record is clear: it was European Zionists whom struck the first blow. It was they whom started a cycle of violence between Arabs and Jews when they committed ethnic cleansing and massacres of Palestinians in 1948, and razed their villages afterward. And stole their land.”

No, Marco, it started when the first Arab fallah stole a cow from a Jewish farmer in the 1880s and has escalated ever since, turning into the Arab massacres of Jews in 1921, 1929 and 1936-9, long before the UN existed and partition became an issue. You show the same “selective history” that is typical of Arab propagandists, pretending that history started with the partition vote.

As for stealing land, when 6 Arab armies attacked in 1948, their intention was to steal everything the Jews in Palestine had built. What of the nearly 1,000,000 Jews expelled from Arab lands, where Jewish-owned land with an area almost five times the total area of Israel including the West Bank and Gaza was stolen by the Arab governments? Your cries about theft are nothing but the cries of a defeated, spiteful and frustrated thief whose intended victim had the temerity to resist successfully—sour grapes from a sore loser.

MV: “The question needing to be asked is: What have Israeli Jews (and all Zionist Jews) done to earn the respect and acceptance of Arabs?”

Let’s see… Israeli Arabs can vote (including the women), have full access to public education including university studies, full access to healthcare, social security, welfare benefits and more employment opportunities than anywhere in the Arab world. The life expectancy of an Israeli Arab is longer than in any Arab country. Infant mortality is lower than in any Arab country. The average per capita earned income is higher than that of any Arab country.

If these aren’t enough to gain anyone’s respect, then their criteria for respect are seriously warped.

Judging from history, the Arab world respects Israel only after they’ve been knocked flat on their collective rear end after another attempt to destroy the country they’re so desperately jealous of—Israel.

MV: “If your response is going to be another one of your typical, boring and infamous 11-page essays then do not bother since I do not waste time reading such posts.”

I’m so sorry of those posts annoy you so—I guess it has something to do with your inability to deal with inconvenient facts.
Add your Comment