Israel Voted, Now What? - Instablogs
Israel Voted, Now What?
Marco Villa , Connecticut: Feb 11 2009
Made Popular Feb 11 2009
Israel :

Israel Voted, Now What?

The result was certainly not what the pundits predicted. It was Kadima led by Tzipi Livni and not Netanyahu and Likud that got the largest bloc in the Knesset. But Israel’s elections aren’t that simply and the pundits were only half-wrong. The victory was, alas, for the right-wing in Israel with an impressive showing for the neo-fascist Israel Is Our Country party that managed to get more votes than the Labour, a party that created Israel.

President Shimon Perez will soon enough ask Netanyahu to attempt to form a government and Bibi will be able to form a rightist bloc [though there is the slight possibility of a rotating Kadima-Likud government akin to that Labor-Likud power sharing in the 1980s].

What will a Netanyahu government, particularly if it includes the racist Avigdor Lieberman, mean for Israel/Palestine?

For starters it will mean the end of the already ineffective peace track with the Palestinians toward a two-state solution. Wit the prospect of a two-state solution, Israel’s Arabs will only grow justifiably less restless with the knowledge that Israel intends to subdue them eternally. Having Lieberman and his loyalty oath on board will only further antagonize Israeli Arabs.

This is what Israel-Palestinians expert Bernard Avishai writes about the prospect of a Netanyahu government:

“MY BET IS that Netanyahu will form a rightist government, take his chances with Washington, the collapse of relations with the PA, and riots among Israeli Arabs.

Brace yourselves.” Indeed.

But what is to happen if a two-state solution is no longer possible? Harvard professor Stephen Walt:

“But if a two-state option is no longer feasible, it seems likely that the United States would come to favor this third choice. After all, supporting option 2 — an apartheid state — is contrary to the core American values of freedom and democracy and would make the United States look especially hypocritical whenever it tried to present itself as a model for the rest of the world. Openly endorsing apartheid would also demolish any hope we might have of improving our image in the Arab and Islamic world. Lord knows I have plenty of respect for the Israel lobby’s ability to shape U.S. foreign policy, but even AIPAC and the other heavyweight institutions in the lobby would have great difficulty maintaining the “special relationship” if Israel was an apartheid state. By contrast, option 3 — a binational state that provided full democratic rights for citizens of all ethnic and religious backgrounds — is easy to reconcile with America’s own “melting pot” traditions and liberal political values. American politicians would find it a hard option to argue against.”

There is evidence that many Israelis and their supports themselves are starting to worry that a two-state solution is ending and that the world will soon start calling for a one-state solution, thus ending the Zionist dream. None other than Shimon Peres took to the pages of The Washington Post to decry the starting chatter about a one-state solution.

“There is no shortage of opinions when it comes to Middle East affairs, and the recent events in Gaza have not muted them. A minority of Middle East pundits have recently emerged as advocates for a one-state solution, which would undermine Israel’s legitimacy and internationally recognized right to exist as a sovereign Jewish state in the land of my forefathers. Having personally witnessed the remarkable progress we have made with the Palestinian Authority in recent years, I believe that a two-state solution is not only the best resolution to this age-old conflict but one within our reach.”

Maybe Peres is right that a two-state solution is still “within out reach.” Otherwise the chatter for a one-state will only grow louder. As Ali Abunimah, founder of the electronic intifidah, writes: “It’s fantastic that they had to roll out Peres in order to defend the two-state solution. They are on the defensive at this level and we have barely even started. It’s all crumbling.”

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Hadi
Tehran, Iran
Now what???????????///////

well nothing!!!!!!!if israel voted in an election there is nothing that one should rejoice...one hypocrite will replace the other...couple of new feigned promises and some sham peace efforts that will again result in nothing but the wicked Israeli plans to grab the Palestinian land? what else? can you expect anything else. if you do, you will be disappointed..
1 Stars
Milind
Thiruvananthapuram, India
@Hadi

To some extant you are right as isreli election is only a Jewish affair and have nothing to do with the the Israeli arabs. they denied United Arab List-Ta'al and Balad from running in parliamentary elections with the bogus accusations of racism from Arab MKs. still Israel is a democratic country and enjoys the most friendly relations with US. But there is other side of the coin as well. Hamas's and Iranian claim to eradicate israel from the map and devoid it the right to exist is something that brings two nations to a brink where from the reconciliation seems impossible but violent breakup imminent. this should be avoided from both sides.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Khor
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
now perhaps Tzipi Livni will take over and she is the one who recommends the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians...Netanyahu is not even going to stop or give occupied land back either but we will keep the fingers crossed to see how their altitude of brutality measure to the one that Olmart did during his reign.
1 Stars
Jordan
Rochester, United States
@ khor and Hadi

why you people are with so much evil conception and one sided views...one may say that israli aggression in Gaza was wrong but attack is the most prominent way to defend... just put yourself in the scenario where the rockets are usually lending in your courtyard and you shiver everytime for your life with the siren or sometimes find a big hole in your roof spoiling everything that you made with the hard earned money...just put urself there and u probably will do the same...
2 Stars
El
Cairo, Egypt
Election and the saga of democracy in the mideast... but All hail for "the only democracy in the Middle East" Democracy my a**, Muslims are denied the vote, can't develop land and off course treated as second class (sub-human) citizens and arab parties are denied to fight election. well form me it is actually democracy at work, and the majority voting away the rights of minority.
1 Stars
Jerry
Jerusalem, Israel
Muslims aren't denied the vote.

this is not true but the facts are provided other way. Arab Israelis can still run for office and Arab Israelis can still vote. The Arab Parties were banned because of their incitement, supporting terrorist groups and refusing to recognize Israel's right to exist. Iam sure as a few of you might be knowing that the current Israeli minister of Science is an Arab. The Israeli Supreme Court has time and time again said Arab Israelis have full rights but that doesn't mean their parties or MKs can break the law.
2 Stars
Robert
Manchester, United Kingdom
It's good to see more moderate Kadima Party having done well in the election and it seems well for future. with this it is highly likely that constructive negotiations with the Palestinians will continue. However, the success of Kadima, to some extant, is counter-acted by the almost equal success of Likud party and tt seems that Israeli politics is once again in a state of un-productive stalemate that will result in zero progress in all the issues that really matter for the geo-political stability in the Mideast.
Add your Comment