CNN's iReport Mishap: The Lesson for Instablogs
Marco Villa (Who am I?) , Connecticut: Oct 5 2008
Made Popular Oct 6 2008
United States :

CNN's iReport Mishap: The Lesson for Instablogs

We here at Instablogs report on hundreds of issue, but few hit home as close as this story. CNN’s much-touted iReport ciziten-journalism recently caused trouble on Wall Street due to the network posting false information from a sender.

An iReport contributor reported that Apple’s CEO Steve Jobs had had a heart attack. Within moments of the post, the companies stock began to dip until Apple quickly responded that CNN’s third-party reporting was false, Mr. Jobs was fine.

The stock then resumed its normal trading pattern. CNN has since removed the post, obviously. But the fact that such false information about a prominent American CEO could be posted, without verification, on the website of one of the United States’ and the world’s most reputable news organization raises serious questions about the conduct of citizen journalism: who are the editors and what are the standards?

Here at Instablog this is something that we all most confront if we wish to maintain the high standards and reputation of our forum. Without fact-checking and proper conduct editing, Instablog could be what CNN iReport became last week: a network for falsehood.

The standards to be maintained are simply and obvious, they are the standards upheld by most news bureaus: honesty, decency and thorough fact-checking. As to who are the editors: we all are. It is up to us in the Instablog community to be each others editors 24/7. We must read one another’s posts and make sure that no one is intentionally spreading falsehoods and indecency (i.e. hate speech).

It also means that as public editors we should offer one another constructive criticism. I invite you all to offer comments on my writings and as an Instablog friend, I will reciprocate the honor.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
3 Stars
Cecilia (Who am I?)
San Jose, United States
Very well said Marco.

I totally agree with you that we can never develop until we grow as truly democratic, and that can only happen when we becoming each others editor.

We need to understand that a platform like this can't be allowed to be misused at any cost, and people should help in developing the story with comments and questions.
3 Stars
Deco (Who am I?)
Manchester, United Kingdom
It is really shocking that anybody did such a thing. Apple has been known for its charismatic CEO who has helped in making Apple household name. And it is no shock that such a news can plummet stock prices of Apple.

And of course CNN people should now understand that every news can't be allowed, they should ask the reporter in important stories to provide a bot of evidence.
4 Stars
Marco Villa

That post is laden with a lot of caution about what a false piece of information could do to the reputation of citizen journalism, here at Instablogs.

When readers must have read the false news about Mr Jobs heart attack, it was not citizen journalism that they relied on, in all probability the reputation of CNN must have made it sound credible.

Building credibility sometimes takes generations, which New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Economist, news agencies like AFP, Reuters, AP, news services like VOA, BBC and a host of others have acquired over time.

We remain a start up, by the standards these organization have reached, but to build credibility, I agree with Marco and we must ensure that false reporting and false propaganda must be countered and stopped from making its way into public domain, if we are to build an credible citizen journalism forum.

Building a reputation takes a generation, damaging it does not take more than a few hours.
1 Stars
Oscar (Who am I?)
Oaxaca, Mexico
i read about this...A highly dangerous and untrue comment was made, causing stocks to drop, scarey...exactly, I think you summed it up.. Everyone must take extreme caution . CJ blogging is great,it allows a true citizens heartfelt opinion, a chance to really walk in the shoes of that person, not just hears a media out-take, but first and foremost you have have the facts, all of them, and correctly.
1 Stars
Hei Marco, i couldnt believe that such a thing happened, as much as we want IB to inform the whole world, we should also be observant and accurate in our work it should be everyone’s responsibility to write, rewrite, read and even re-read before making any postings, we cannot afford to loose the momentum that IB/CJ has taken, we Should also be each one’s keeper by making sure that correct information reaches the public and ensure that we are the source of objective nad balanced stories that do not misinform the public who have entrusted us with keeping them updated on different issues, its my sincere call to all members to fulfil our course as duly required.
1 Stars
Marco! Thank you for this article.. I have read a couple of stories on it and they are all seriously questioning citizen journalism.

Like you say, we all editors... Its our responsibility to make sure that whatever we post is not malicious, hatred,... we all know it.

Let us not flash this young next best thing to happen to us all down the drain.

Its simple: Let us report the news as it happens, nothing less or more!
1 Stars
Marco! Thank you for this article.. I have read a couple of stories on it and they are all seriously questioning citizen journalism.

Like you say, we all editors... Its our responsibility to make sure that whatever we post is not malicious, hatred,... we all know it.

Let us not flash this young next best thing to happen to us all down the drain.

Its simple: Let us report the news as it happens, nothing less or more!
1 Stars
S.k. (Who am I?)
kolkata, India
I guess falsehood is involved in all propagandist reporting, some Indian news channels vouching for it to give their news pieces a conscious glaze!

but this here is a serious issue!

but i think, not sparing the CJ the CNN bureau is more at blame for not verifyng the news in the first place!

I think the enquiries it made after it published the news could have been done earlier as well to save its face!
Add your Comment