Arab-American Group Challenges Tax-Exempt Status of Pro-Settler Groups - Instablogs
Arab-American Group Challenges Tax-Exempt Status of Pro-Settler Groups
Marco Villa , Connecticut: Apr 2 2009
Made Popular Apr 2 2009
Israel :

I recently wrote about how the U.S. tax-code grants tax-exempt status to American groups fund raising to aid illegal Israeli settlements on the West Bank; advancing goals in violation of international law and the American government’s stated policy of opposing settlements.

The work that these organization do is no small chicken. “IRS records identified 28 U.S. charitable groups that made a total of $33.4 million in tax-exempt contributions to settlements and related organizations between 2004 and 2007,” Washington Post columnist David Ignatius reported.

Arab-American Group Challenges Tax-Exempt Status of Pro-Settler Groups

It is clear what needs to be done. If Obama is serious about stopping Israeli settlements and bringing about peace, then a good first step should ban any American donations towards settlements. And I mean that they should be banned outright not just have tax-exemption revoked. The United States government should declare donations to be contrary to U.S. goals and interests, and contrary to international law. Because such donations prop-up illegal behavior they should be banned. The United States governments bans donations to terrorist groups and it also banned American aid, private or public, to reconstruction efforts in Lebanon after Israel’s war because, it states, aid would probably filter to Hezbollah. If the U.S. can ban aid to help the Lebanese rebuild all because the aid may filter to Hezbollah, then the government can and should ban aid to illegal, violent and apartheid-based Israeli settlements.

And now the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee has filed a motion with the U.S. Treasury Department to investigation these organizations. The organization stated in their press release:

Today, the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC) filed multiple administrative complaints with the US Department of the Treasury, including the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), requesting investigations into the activities of organizations claiming tax-exempt status under section 501(C)3 of the US Tax Code yet allegedly raising funds for the development of illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank. Among other allegations, the ADC complaints allege that these organizations are using assets and income in direct violation of their addressed purpose, and to support illegal and terrorist activities abroad

They added,

The construction of settlements in occupied territory is illegal under international humanitarian law. The use of tax-exempt status to raise funds for these types of activities is also illegal under US law. Further, it is a central part of stated US policy toward the Arab-Israeli conflict that settlement expansion and construction must stop. In filing its complaints, ADC seeks to ensure that US tax laws are not being exploited, and violated, by certain organizations which are allegedly using their tax-exempt status contradictory to stated US policies on this issue.

Now the question is will anything come out of this? Will the American government end the tax-exempt status or better still band fund raising for illegal activity all together?

I doubt it. The Israel lobby would strongly protest. Further, why would the U.S. government enforce a private restriction on aid when the U.S. government is itself giving Israeli aid and loans that have been used for West Bank settlements?

And, yes, Virginia there is an Israel lobby.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Markus
Mexico City, Mexico
stupid americans.

america supplies weapons, the people who get them use it against them, america sends troops to fight their own weapons. and repeat.

follow these steps to keep a country stupid for several decades.
1 Stars
Fahood
Al-Manamah, Bahrain
Can someone please tell me why America always seems to be protecting Israel? Is it because thats where Jesus was supposedly born??
1 Stars
Ryan
Los Angeles, United States
Speaking from pure experience growing up in this country, but Jews seemed to be the strongest religious minority in this country. I've lived in many states in many years, and always at least one (if not more) of my good friends were always Jewish. I think, maybe, that they simply blend in well with American society as a whole. Not to mention their historical significance in the development of this country from its conception.
2 Stars
Stephanie
Phoenix, United States
Israel is a democracy and is under attack by the same terrorists that want to destroy the US. Isn't it obvious why the US is giving Israel support?
1 Stars
Reza
Tehran, Iran
Less than 100 million Jews worldwide.
More than 1 billion Muslims worldwide.

Shouldn't we at least try to be friends with 1 billion people than pick a fight with them?
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Tom
Brisbane, Australia
Damn Michael, You’ve banged it on the face of 1 billions who’s aim is to spread hate in the rest of the world. Cheers!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Mike
Columbus, United States
Great reply Michael. We are with you man!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Kyle
New York, United States
This is to all the Muslims who think that they are the most deprived sect of the world:

People all over the world want to live in peace and harmony with each other. But you guys constantly prick one or the other and unnecessarily crib all the time. May be its to gain attention. There are millions of Muslims who are peace loving and have good relations with other communities.

My suggestion is, stop crying that you are deprived because you are not. Everyone is ready to give you the equal opportunities till the time you keep your mind on track. But when you try to impose your rigid rules on rest, it becomes unreasonable hence intolerable. So, to get respect, start behaving like a sane human being.
2 Stars
Nahum Y
Gaza, Palestine
@ Michael
Collective contribution? They are contributing collectively in the miseries of Palestinian people (particularly the children and women).
1 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
I don’t think there should be tax exempt status for any group. It is too easy to exploit the charity label.
1 Stars
Michael Davison
Raanana, Israel
To Nahum:

I beg to differ. You Palestinian Arabs could have had a state more than once, but refused each time: in 1937, the Peel Commission offered 80% of the Mandate for a Palestinian Arab state and 20% for the Palestinian Jews, yet it was the Arabs who refused. In 1947, the UN voted on a partition plan, and again it was the Palestinian Arabs (and the entire Arab world) that refused. Again in 2000, at Camp David, Arafat was offered the West Bank & Gaza, yet he refused, walked out and initiated the second intifada without even making a counter-offer.

I’d say that the Palestinian Arabs have had a hand in making their own misery, too.

By the way, do you feel that the Hamas aim of a Palestinian state from the river to the sea is the only answer? If you do, then I’m afraid we might have nothing to negotiate over at all.
1 Stars
Michael Davison
Raanana, Israel
I hope that whoever deleted my previous post doesn’t delete this one, as well.
Add your Comment